Tag: Compilation
Q. Is there any connection between Sri Dasam Granth and the British?
The sacred Banee of Sri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib has guided the Khalsa for the last 300 years and is part and parcel of the Sikh psyche. Sri Dasam Granth of Sri … Continue Reading →
Q. Is it true that Chhand 201 in Akal Ustat which reads as Atma Uchrio & four Chhands 126-130 in Gian Prabodh were in fact written by Atma Ram?
It’s another classical example of a conspiracy theory hatched by Jasbir Singh Mann. As Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha explains in Mahan Kosh, the ten Dohras (201 to 210) in Akal … Continue Reading →
Q. Is it true that a Nirmala priest Atma Ram of Calcutta worked with Mahants at Patna to create, compile and promote this Gurmukhi Granth titled “Dasmi Patshahi Ka Granth” in Devnagri?
In the numerous texts of the 19th century there is no mention of any Atma Ram working with any Mahant at Patna. One important 19th century text is Sri Gur … Continue Reading →
Q. Is there any evidence that shows that British introduced Dasam Granth to strip the Sikhs of the spirit of independence and warfare?
This is another baseless claim that Jasbir Singh Mann started some years ago, without any hard historical evidence. If the British aimed at stripping the Sikhs of their military might … Continue Reading →
Q. Is there any internal evidence showing the date when Dasam Granth was written?
This question is never asked about the creation of the Sri Guru Granth Sahib, and as Sri Dasam Granth is the work of Guru Gobind Singh Ji this is also … Continue Reading →
Q. Chaubees Avtar, Chritropakhyan and Bachitra Natak writings were the works of poets, Bhatts and pandits etc. Guru Sahib publicized these as his own. Is it true?
Question. Chaubees Avtar, Chritropakhyan and Bachitra Natak writings were the works of poets, Bhatts and pandits etc. and Guru Gobind Singh had simply given recognition to these banees. In order … Continue Reading →
Q. If Bachittar Natak is the autobiography of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, then why there is no mention of Vaisakhi 1699 (Amirt Sanskar), battle of Chamkaur Sahib, and martyrdom of the younger Sahibzades?
Question. If Bachittar Natak is the autobiography of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, then why there is no mention of Vaisakhi 1699 (Amirt Sanskar), battle of Chamkaur Sahib, and martyrdom of … Continue Reading →
Q. Is it true that since the time of the writing of Dasam Granth, there has been a controversy about its authorship?
Question. Is it true that since the time of the writing of Dasam Granth, there has been a controversy about its authorship? Answer. No it is not true. There had … Continue Reading →
Q. Did Guru Gobind Singh Ji mention anywhere in his writing that he was actually writing/compiling a ‘Granth’?
Question. Did Guru Gobind Singh Ji mention anywhere in his writing that he was actually writing/compiling a ‘Granth’? Answer. Guru Gobind Singh ji Maharaj was not only the master of … Continue Reading →